Study finds presumed shared parenting is not in the interests of children

Proposed legislation to introduce and enforce a presumption of shared parenting time for separating couples is not in the interests of children, according to a study published today by the Department of Social Policy and Intervention at the University of Oxford.

The term ‘shared parenting' has no legal status but generally refers to a child spending an equal amount of time with each parent. Two Private Members' Bills currently before Parliament seek to introduce and enforce a default position that children should spend a substantial amount of time with both parents in the event of separation.

Academics from the University of Oxford and Australia analysed the proposed legislation in light of research evidence on shared parenting, with particular reference to Australia, which introduced similar legislation in 2006.

They concluded that introducing a default presumption that children should spend a substantial amount of time with both parents would overturn the provision in the Children Act 1989 that the welfare of the child should be paramount in deciding contact issues.

The researchers found no empirical evidence that increasing the amount of time spent with a non-resident parent improves outcomes for children. It is the quality of the relationship between parents and between parents and children, as well as practical resources such as housing and income that are important for children's well-being, not equal or near equal parenting time.

According to the study, shared parenting works best when separated parents are co-operative and flexible. However cases that end up in court are often characterised by conflict between parents and concerns about child welfare. The researchers conclude that the cases subject to shared parenting legislation will be those in which shared parenting is least likely to be successful.

Mavis Maclean, joint Director of the Oxford Centre for Family Law and Policy and one of the briefing paper's authors said: "Children benefit from a meaningful relationship with both parents, but there is no evidence for legislating to prioritise shared parenting time over any other parenting arrangement. Instead, we should identify ways to assist separated parents to think carefully about arrangements that will best serve their children's needs, and to put those above their own views."