‘Neither a borrower nor a lender be; For loan oft loses both itself and friend’: A review of the law on family loans – was Shakespeare right?

Anna Roiser and Eri Horrocks Hunters Law

This article considers how the courts approach (purported) loans from family members in financial remedy proceedings and the variety of situations in which disputes can arise. Whilst in some cases there may be a dispute as to whether there was ever a transaction at all in most cases it is the nature of a transaction which is in issue.

Debate is generally framed around whether a transaction was a 'soft' or 'hard' loan with the line between a soft loan and a gift narrowing almost to extinction in some cases but remaining distinct in others. An examination of the caselaw illustrates that the significance of how a family loan is characterised can be felt in two ways: firstly whether it will be included in the overall asset computation and secondly whether provision for repayment should be made in the order.

here.