Spotlight
Court of Protection Practice 2024
'Court of Protection Practice goes from strength to strength, having...
Jackson's Matrimonial Finance Tenth Edition
Jackson's Matrimonial Finance is an authoritative specialist text...
Spotlight
Latest articlesrss feeds
Fast, accurate Drug, Alcohol & DNA testing
***SPONSORED CONTENT***Rachel Davenport, Co-founder and Director at AlphaBiolabs, breaks down everything you need to know about AlphaBiolabs’ industry-leading laboratory testing services for legal...
Family Justice Council publishes ‘Guidance on responding to a child’s unexplained reluctance, resistance or refusal to spend time with a parent and allegations of alienating behaviour’
The Family Justice Council (FJC) has published guidance for Family judiciary, and those working in the Family Justice System, on responding to allegations of alienating behaviour.The guidance, which...
Children's Commissioner report: Deaths of children in need
The Children’s Commissioner has published a new report as to the deaths of Children In Need.‘Child in need’ is an umbrella term including looked after children, children on a child protection plan,...
NSPCC and others respond to the Sara Sharif verdict
On 11 December 2024 the CPS announced that Urfaqn Sharif, father of Sara Sharif, a ten year old girl, and stepmother, Beinash Batool, had been convicted of her murder. Sara’s uncle, Faisal Malik, who...
Allegations of inflicted injuries in children: is Omeprazole the new EDS? Dark corners of medicine, science, the unknown unknowns and the wider canvas
Tina Cook KC, 42 Bedford RowThis article considers the importance of medical and genetic research in shining light into possible causes of fractured bones in suspected non accidental injury allegation...
View all articles
Authors

Can I use the Family Court to issue a freestanding TOLATA claim?

Sep 29, 2018, 21:18 PM
TOLATA, Civil Courts Structure Review Report, Briggs LJ, family law, Schedule 1, family court, Graeme Fraser
Title : Can I use the Family Court to issue a freestanding TOLATA claim?
Slug : can-i-use-the-family-court-to-issue-a-freestanding-tolata-claim
Meta Keywords : TOLATA, Civil Courts Structure Review Report, Briggs LJ, family law, Schedule 1, family court, Graeme Fraser
Canonical URL :
Trending Article : No
Prioritise In Trending Articles : No
Check Copyright Text : No
Date : Aug 15, 2016, 08:34 AM
Article ID : 114752
The Civil Courts Structure Review Report by Lord Justice Briggs, published at the end of July 2016, intends to provide clarity about the running of TOLATA claims to those who use the Family Court.

When the Family Court was introduced in April 2014, no specific provision was made for freestanding TOLATA claims to be brought there. The Family Division of the High Court already has jurisdiction to deal with both family and civil matters. However, the intention of recent reforms has been to reserve the work of the Family Division for complex international cases and matters pertaining to its inherent jurisdiction. It is not clear, therefore, that freestanding TOLATA claims can be commenced in the Family Court.

The situation is problematic when using those court buildings which accommodate the Family Court but not the county court, a situation which occurs at the busy Central Family Court in London. This can lead to the necessity of issuing the application in the Family Division with a view to transferring the proceedings to the Central Family Court. This issue becomes complicated if a Sch 1 application is brought together with a TOLATA claim. Assuming the TOLATA claim cannot automatically be issued, an argument can be run for district judges in the Central Family Court to assume the powers as if they were sitting in the High Court to enable the TOLATA claim and Sch 1 application to be heard together. John Wilson QC describes this as a 'depressingly sterile debate' (Cohabitation Claims, 2nd end, 2015), expressing the hope for the issue to be resolved by judgment or rule change or practice direction.

In his final report, Lord Justice Briggs confirms his provisional recommendation that the Family Court be given TOLATA jurisdiction 'so as to put right what appears to have been an omission at the time of the creation of that court'. He also considers that the preservation of a shared jurisdiction by the Family and Civil Courts in a way which ensures that the whole of any particular dispute can be fully dealt with in one set of proceedings in one court or the other is preferable to attempts to carve out exclusive jurisdiction in relation to a subject which, by its nature, straddles the two.

These recommendations are to be welcomed as a means of providing clarity and avoiding potentially disproportionate arguments regarding procedure in TOLATA claims. However, it highlights the breadth of TOLATA remedies which cover commercial as well as domestic property situations. Surely the best way of distinguishing those claims would be to introduce specific family law remedies for cohabitants - but this remains a task for Parliament.

Follow Graeme Fraser on Twitter @gsf1996.
Categories :
  • Articles
Tags :
royal_courts_justice_3
Provider :
Product Bucket :
Recommend These Products
Load more comments
Comment by from